
Tina
 |
Simon is the one in the know. He knows the music business like the back of his hand. He can be a little brutal but the man knows what sells and what doesn't. |
|

beemerharley
|
Paula and the dude in the red white and blue was BAD |
|

wlvrne1964
|
Randy seems to be the most objective.
Paula can be swayed by guys she thinks are good-looking.
Simon, I like his acerbic approach, but there's really no call to insult people like he does. I'm sure he does it for the ratings. |
|

hectorthe4runner
|
Randy. Doesn't sugar coat it (Paula) and doesn't over criticize (Simon). |
|

Ambien
|
I like Simon.... raises the entertainment value of the show. But Randy is quite objective, so thats good. But if I have to choose one.......... RANDY |
|

iAmGirl
 |
Paula is very wishy washy. Simon is looking for a real talent, I like that. Randy laughs at everyone...and that's pretty funny to me. :) |
|

agedmomma
 |
Simon. He is straight to the point and tells it like it is. |
|

girl.loves.Flyers
 |
Simon is the most honest judge. As harsh as he can be, he at least tells people how it is. A lot of people on that show really cannot sing and would never make it in the music business. I think Simon is the best. You have to admire him a little, who else can be that up-front? I would love to tell some people how I feel but don't because I don't want to hurt their feelings. Then later I wished that I would have said what was really on my mind. |
|

Jaim Jaim
 |
RANDY. He makes the most sense and I agree with him most of the time. He can be honest in a nice way. Simon is just Simon and Paula is just too nicey nicey, lol. |
|

ridgeracergt
 |
Simon because he is the only honest one. |
|

leebeeguy
|
I would say Simon because he is the honest one even though he may be mean he just speaking the truth |
|

rebecca1
 |
I like Simon the best because he knows how to lay it on the line. I appreciate his honesty and his ability to not beat around the bush! |
|

Randolph
|
As for my wife and me, we both love Paula. She can hear the musical notes she is looking for. She is nice and we don't care what other people think about her. She tends to be a loving person. And she acts like a Christian. |
|

Swordsman
 |
Paula. |
|

katherine ann
 |
I prefer Simon, he isn't afraid to tell the contestents that they suck, if they do. |
|

| |
|