Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Financial Forum Search :
   Homepage      News      Financial Topics     Finance Directories      Financial Forum      Dictionary  
Financial Forum    Renting & Real Estate
Finance Discussion Forum

 If I complete a rental application and get approved, does that mean I am now bound the apartment?
I am now waiting on more paperwork to fill out but I would like to know if this application means I've signed my life to this apartment and there's no turning back. Currently, I am waiting ...


 How to handle a Sect 8 tenant who is angry and irrational?
A Sect 8 tenant receiving disability moved into my unit recently. This tenant demanded to move in early before rent check was received, called at 11:30 am that night, made a list of 50 or more items ...


 ARM vs. Fixed Rate?
We can either get a 5/1 ARM or my parents can loan me money and we can get the fixed rate for 30 years. Which would you do right now???
Additional Details
I will pay my parents back by ...


 How do I get into real estate business?
Everytime I ask around to find out how to get into the business they always tell me you need a lots of investment. It is very discouraging..so I need help! Is there a webstie?...


 If i rent an house from a private landlord, will we usually sign a proper contract?
is it in my rights?...


 Looking to refinance mortgage...any good companies?
...


 I am moving into a new apartment July 31st and came to agreement that this would be okay. Apt managemis tryin
to change move in date to the 20th of july whis is total bs and will cost me an additional 400 dollars that I am not willing to spend. My rent is paid through the first at the place I live at now. I...


 Can a tennant give a 30 day notice and assume the security deposit will be used?
When you give a 30 day notice for example of the 27th, on the 1st do you still have rent due? Is it fair for the tennant to ask that the security deposit be used as rent?...


 Question about refinancing my home.?
Say, for the sake of arguement, that I currently have a mortgage for 100K. I heard that I can refinance my home (at whatever the current market interest rate is, which just happens to be lower then ...


 My Mother in law has messed up our mortgage payment and I'm worried?
OK this is going to be long so bear with me.

Last year we fell into arrears with our mortgage. We went to court, a suspended possession order was granted, but we managed to raise the ...


 NEW home buyer question??
Im looking to purchase a new home if i find a house selling for 80,000 but worth 100,000 can i get the loan for what the house is worth so i can have extra money to take care of other things???does ...


 I'm looking to move down south. I need suggestions and/or recommendations for which city to move to?
Hello,

I am currently a resident of Buffalo, NY. I have about a year and a half of school left (I'm in grad school).

Anyway, 27 years of cold weather, high taxes, and a ...


 People who rent - I need an idea of how much I can expect to pay on bills each month?
It will be a small house, not sure which council tax band. I know it varies, i just need a rough estimate
Additional Details
I'm talking about bills, beside rent. i.e water, gas, ...


 If the bank you have a mortgage with goes bust, what happens to your mortgage?
...


 When you purchase property, are items left on it yours after closing?
I recently purchased 2 acres of land in the country. The day of closing, I went first out to look at it again, and I noticed that there was still a box blade for a tractor on the back of the ...


 If a potential landlord says he'll call tonight, but doesn't, should I call him?
I was told that I was on the "very short list" of people he would rent a house to. He said he would probably be making calls tonight. If he doesn't call me by 8 PM, should I go ahead ...


 Can i sell property by eBay?
i would like to sell my old house in Bulgaria, can i use eBay for this purpouse?...


 Can an agreed mortgage offer be withdrawn?
...


 I own my own condo. I am going to be travelling abroad?
I own my own condo. Lovely condo. All mine. Right by the lake. I will be travelling for a few months, back to my country. Some people will be coming into redecorate, and a co-worker coming in a ...


 Any lawyers in the house ?
I took out a mortgage to purchase my home before my husband and I got married although he did come and live in it with me. We are married now and I was wondering, if we split up, would I have to ...



lildove1960
Breaking a lease?
My daughter recently signed a year lease with her best friend, after living there for 3 days the friend moved out, my daughter ran an ad and found a roommate after a month, now the friend is suing my daughter for return of her deposit,,in my opinion the friend broke the lease forfeiting the deposit, regardless of what the new roommate paid. Has anyone been through this, and been sued, what was the outcome, any answers would be appreciated.
                     
 




KYRealEstateGuy
Rating
I agree with you. And if you really want to get technical about it. The deposit was paid to the landlord, not your daughter. Leases are meant to commit people to a set of terms, so I have very little pity for those that break their commitments and then try to get every penny back out.


lisa
Rating
Did both sign the lease agreement? I wouldn't give the "friend" anything, in fact, I'd consider counter-sueing if both signed. What a pain in the neck! I'm glad she found another roommate.


Belle
The friend would be entitled to her deposit if she left for a major reason. An example of this would be if she were in a dangerous situation. If she feared (with proof) for her own personal safety, she could legally break her lease. Also, if a roommate is posing a threat to her (doing drugs, bringing in strangers) or something like that, she would be awarded her deposit. However, just leaving because of personal conflict, she would have to sacrifice her deposit. Also, I will add that she had the burden of helping your daughter find a replacement, which she obviously didn't do. So, unless she had a viable reason for leaving, she does not get her deposit back. Maybe she should've watched Judge Judy first and learn this herself. :)


urrrp
Rating
I assume your daughter is named on the lease. The lease is between your daughter and the landlord. I assume the other girl put up half of the deposit and your daughter put up the other half of the deposit. I assume there was no agreement between your daughter and the other girl about the deposit.

Here is the deal - the other girl did not "break the lease" because it doesn't sound to me like she was ever on the lease. Your daughter is on the lease. You may have thought that there was some kind of agreement between your daughter and the other girl about the deposit, but unless such an agreement was reached, there was no ageement. Also, why is the other girl suing your daughter and not the landlord who, presumably, is the one holding the deposit?


scooshy
i don't think she could be sued for breaking the lease in fact if anyone could have to lose the money it the person who broke the lease not your daughter
as for getting sued that's a bit of a joke
tell you're daughter not to worry about the old friend and get on with her life without her i think she would be better off


connemara
To whom did the friend pay the security deposit? Directly to your daughter? She should have paid it to the landlord. If the latter is true and the friend's name is on the lease, she needs to deal with the landlord. If the latter is true but her name is not on the lease, she is SOL. If however, the friend paid your daughter directly, then personally, I would refund the money minus the cost of running ads to find a new roommate. Why risk all the animosity and a lawsuit? Really, it's not worth the aggravation. This is why it is rarely if ever a good idea to rent with "a friend." Actuallly, renting with anyone else usually leads to disaster somehwere down the road. And besides, the so-called friend could really only take your daughter to small claims court on this one, since the amount of money involved is I am assuming, well under $5,000. Have your daughter pay the biddy and be rid of her!


My two cents
I cant say for sure, but you do sound right. Because if say, your daughter rented the place by herself, she would be giving up her non refundable deposit. Go over the lease and make sure that it does say non refundable. Even so, the person she should be suing for her money back should be the landlord, not the tenant, after all, she doesnt have the money, it has been handed over. Good luck!


Princesa
Rating
I think you are correct, the roommate did break the lease therefore should not expect her deposit back. You might want to try consulting the www.peopleslawyer.net.


Joel
I am assuming that they both signed a lease with the landlord not each other, however it is for this purpose basicaly the same result. the judge would throw it out for 2 reasons.... number one, both are responcable for the entire rent for a year. the fact that your daughter found somone to carry her friends portion, does not exuse the friend of that responcability. that is why a deposit is posted to garrenty the contract is followed through on.... there is a consumer law issue in which someone can back out of a lease in 3 days with the landlord, however if she didnt do that, she has no right left.

If I were your daughter I would counter sue for lost rent for the days she had to pay the rent alone, utilities for that time, the time and/or cost of finding the new person ect..... your daughter would win..... to save a friendship ( if it is worth it) she wouldnt have to docket the judgement of collect on it.


NYC Chutzpah
Rating
Has the new roommate given your daughter the money for the deposit?, if so I would refund the ex roommate's deposit money minus the cost of finding a new roommate IE cost of the ad and a little bit for aggravation


 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:







Archive: Forum -Forum -Finance - Links - 1 - 2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
The Causes and the Results. 0.014
Copyright (c) 2011 Financial Crisis Monday, May 28, 2012 - Terms of use - Privacy Policy