kellyrv_bsa
|
you can ask, but be careful how you ask. Niceness counts. He (the landlord) does not have to |
|
Cutiepie
 |
Its your responsibility as the tenant to clean it. The owner does not have to replace it. Sorry. |
|
Knowit A
|
Ask. If you don't ask you'll never know! |
|
dddddd
|
you can but it might not happen |
|
halfpint6niner
|
You family didn't just develop asthma from an old carpet. Since you have been there 4 years have you ever thought of renting a steam cleaner and cleaning it? You should also clean the walls and windows and other stuff. |
|
Questions?
 |
yes you can request it but it dosnt mean they definatly will do it |
|
Logic316
|
A wall-to-wall carpet is a part of the apartment, so if it's old and creating a health hazard or other dangerous condition (such as dust, holes, etc). then the landlord should replace it at his expense as long as you didn't damage it or cause any unreasonable wear and tear. Since you mentioned that it was already worn when you moved in, he shouldn't hold you responsible for it. You did take photos of the carpet when you moved in, right? |
|
Anonymous
|
Don't think the landlord is responsible for the carpet. |
|
happysingle
|
Laws vary from state to state but usually the manager is not responsible for either cleaning the carpet or replacing it while you are a tenant, as long as it is in reasonable shape when you move in. After you move out and b4 someone else moves in they are responsible to either clean or replace unless your lease makes you responsible for doing so. |
|
CrG
|
You should have asked in the beginning. You would have had a better chance. There is no law, and if he does it, it will be out of the kindness of his heart. He is under no obligation. |
|
pancakke
|
You can request your landlord change the carpet but they may not.
I think it is your place to clean the carpet in the apartment. Four years is a long time to let a carpet go without cleaning it. |
|
.......
|
It is your responsibility to keep the dwelling clean. That includes cleaning the carpeting. If the carpeting is beyond repair and your family is getting sick, then you should have an honest conversation with your landlord about making improvements. They rented the apartment to you in the condition that it was in. Unless the contract specifies that they are to make improvements, then they are not obliged to do so. Many land lords will grant requests to keep a good renter. Good luck. |
|
freestyleQUEEN
 |
Yes, he has to change, if it is causing health problems. As a matter of fact, if it was as old as you say it is, he should've replaced it before you moved in. He sounds pretty dumb, because he's actually setting hisself up for a law suit. I don't know the landlord- tennant laws where you live, but i do know, if you suffer health problems do to his/her negligence you are intitled to a claim. You should take this matter up with the board of health and file a civil claim. In the mean-while you should check out your states landlord- tennant laws. If you really love your home so much and you adore your health, I would change the carpet myself and hand him the bill, or tell him to deduct it from your rent if you don't want any problems. |
|
agutieres
|
the carpet shud of been replaced when u moved in...u can tell him wats goin on with u and ur family geting sick hell have to change it....i dont know the landlord laws there..but im positive when it comes to ur health they have to do something about it..
heres a site for tenant right....and laws in new york
goood luck......by the way i had the same problem and my landlord cahnged my carpet |
|
towanda
|
Most tenants shampoo their own carpets. I wouldn't replace yours if you haven't cleaned the one that's in there. If your asthma is triggered by the old carpet, it will probably be bothered by a new carpet too. Most carpet have a minimum life time of 10 years. With good care they can last substantially longer than that. You sound like the guy on here that was complaining because his landlord charged him for having to clean the blinds when he moved out. He thought that was outrageous but the blinds were clean when he moved in. Same with carpets. If your carpet was stained, that's one thing. But if it was clean, you need to keep it clean. Why don't you have a nice conversation with your landlord and ask him if he would clean your carpet for you. Tell him you're having trouble. Or ask him if he would replace the carpet, that it is old and not very nice looking. But first, please learn more about asthma. My friend has asthma and she has no drapes or carpet in her house. The dust that gathers in carpets is killer to her. And if you don't keep your carpets clean, wouldn't you end up with the same dilemma? Think about tile. . . |
|
stargirl
|
Thats on your own there. He just fixes stuff and pays bills. Decor and stuff like that is up to you. Unless he is willing. |
|
Classy Granny
|
The landlord is never responsible for cleaning carpet, that is your job including cleaning it when you move out. If it is old carpet you might get a landlord to replace it but they are not required to. I doubt your asthma developed because of the carpet. |
|
PunkRockPrincess
|
well u could do that and most likely your landlord will refuse, so either find a new place or replace the carpet yourself,otherwise u will only cause your asthma to get worse. |
|
marco b
|
u can i kive in indiana and our carpet was really stained fr some reason and we jst asked our land lord if she could change te carpet and she said yes id give it a shot if i were u but if e says no then idk wat to say |
|
Willow Natalia
|
If your lease states that you are responsible for carpet cleaning upon move out, then no, the landlord is not responsible for having the carpet professionally cleaned on a regular basis. Carpet ages, it's a fact of life. Perhaps when you moved in it was something he was considering but wasn't fully sold on at the time. If he hasn't been by to see the carpet lately, request an inspection so that he can see the shape it's in. He may decide to have it changed, as an investment in his property. It's a major hassle to do when there are tenants, though, so don't be surprised if he says no.
You can ask if he'd let you change the carpet for a reduction in rent, but that's not very likely. Just don't change it on your own. There's probably a clause in your lease that states that no changes are to be made to the unit without the landlord's approval. |
|
jbloor@att.net
 |
I'm a landlord, and you're entitled to 'ask' anything. You can never prove that the old carpet is causing asthma - never been done. Approach your landlord with sweetness and a plate of brownies or cookies. Tell him you'll split the cost 'since this a health concern of yours, PERSONALLY, and nothing that is his fault." If you have 4+ yrs with a good payment history; trust me, he values you as a tenant. (I know I would!). If he has a soul at all, he'll do it for free, or you'll only pay 1/3 cost. Be gracious and let him choose the color, as he has to rent it again when you are gone. Trust me; the 'pretty please?' approach works much better than the 'Don't you think you owe me?' approach. Be mindful and consider: Has he NOT chosen to raise the rent because he factored in that you had not previously asked for new carpet? Did he NOT raise the rent even tho his taxes, insurance, and water have increased these past 4 yrs? I once had a tenant who was crabby and unreasonable as he demanded improvements. I complied with his requests and promptly raised his rent. In the end, he could've saved himself thousands over the long haul, if he had only asked me 'nicely'. |
|
emmamcleod76
|
yes,if you have a lease agreement from when you first moved in and a condition report you are in the right.if he still refuses you can take photos and then take your landlord to the tribunal thats what we call it im from australia so the rules may be different but dont give up good luck mate |
|
senior2tor
|
Carpets can take a lot of bleaching just do it evenly |
|
angel_eyes024
|
I"m not sure what the laws are, but I'm sure they should have been re-done by now...Atleast it doesn't hurt to ask... |
|
Joey m
|
You can request that your landlord do anything to improve your apartment. That doesn't mean that he will do it.
If you've been a good tenant, paid your rent on time, etc., chances are good that he will do it. If not, maybe it's time to go apartment shopping. |
|
Tim F
 |
I am unsure about the specific laws in the state of New Jersey. However, make your landlord aware of your concerns and allergies as a result. In my personal experience, landlords have been pretty open as long as you present your case in a logical manner.
As a last resort, tell him you are considering leaving if the condition is not rectified and will notify the appropriate authorities.
Best of luck! |
|
versantly
|
absolutely, but he may not do it. use your contacts to find someone who can help. since you are using the carpet daily, it is your responsibility to clean it annually -you can always submit the receipt to the landlord for partial reimbursement. otherwise, move. |
|
Shirley
|
Legally, I believe a landlord should change the carpet in your apartment after 5 years due to normal wear and tear. However, they may try to do something sneaky like raise your rent at the next opportunity, to try and re-coup some of the costs.
You may want to hire a professional cleaning company to come in and clean the carpets, if you feel that is a possibility first. It depends how deep the dirt has accumilated.
If you have a good relationship with your landlord, discuss your options with them. Of course, you have to take into consideration the health of your family as well.
Each state may vary where the landlord-tenant rules apply. |
|
Balack Orama
|
The only probable clause would be landlord is responsible for maintenance of premises |
|
Grapeape
|
i dont know about any laws never lived there myself but i would think so defiantely especially given the circumstances. |
|
Cynthia
|
It depends on your lease whether it's your responsibility to clean it or his. It would be his responsibility to change it, or at least have you get it changed and take the price off of your rent. I'd ask your landlord about it - especially if it's causing health issues. |
|
| |
|
Homepage 
Financial
Forum 
Renting & Real Estate 
No Spam
Adult 
Gambling
Unfinished
Deception
Plagiarism
Not English
