Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Financial Forum Search :
   Homepage      News      Financial Topics     Finance Directories      Financial Forum      Dictionary  
Financial Forum    Taxes
Finance Discussion Forum

 If you buy turbo tax software from store is it good for one year only or can you use it in years to come?
please only answer if you know dont ...


 Can you claim a child even if they did not live with you during the past year?
I have custody papers that say that I can claim my daughter, but she has lived with her dad for the past 20 months. Should I claim her or not?
Additional Details
I am actually the child&...


 Do I get to claim mortgage interest that was payed in 2006 on my tax refund.?
If so, would I do it on a 1040? Do I get the whole amount back? If you could just answer to the best of your knowledge. I know that answers isn't for legal advice. I'm jsut trying to get ...


 Does anybody know how much tax is cut from minimum wage in the UK? Thanx?
...


 How long after the deadline did you receive your stimulus check?
My check is being mailed no later than July 4th (a holiday) so when can I expect my check in the mail? The letter says it should be here a few days after, but since it's a holiday I'm not ...


 I just got married. What last name should I use to file my tax returns for this year?
This may be a stupid question, but do I use my married name or my maiden name? I ask because I still get checks from work with my maiden name and have not changed my bank account yet. However, I ...


 So does the Pizza Hut waitress need to report to the IRS the $10,000 tip?
...


 If i am sacked due to illness will i be able claim benefits?
due to illness i have had alot of time off.my work have told me either to leave or be sacked.my doctor has advised me to leave. but i have just been told if i leave i cant claim benfits if i am ...


 How can you track your federal income tax return?
its been about 8 weeks since i sent in my federal tax return and i need to know how i can find out if it was ...


 My financial advisor told me I can claim my meals, mileage, haircuts and...?
and clothing on my taxes for my work. I am employed, not an independant contractor. I go to the location in my town twice a week, and travel 66 miles 3 days a week to another town. I don't ...


 Bloomin Hell?
If you click on all the countries under taxation, USA has 2 questions, others none (I think) and UK 38+ questions. Is our tax system that bad?...


 If i bought an item on ebay from an international seller. Would I get taxed when it is posted to me in the UK?
More specifically i was looking to buy a sports racket. The listed price from power sellers in Hong kong looks cheap. Would I get taxed by the customs here in UK when the package arrives. And if so, ...


 Is there a standing reward of $100,000.00$ to anyone that can provide a law requiring you to file a tax return
a tax code rule that says if you are required to file a Federal Tax return then you must file dose exist.
But you are not required to file....


 What are my options if I forgot to pay peroperty tax before dec 10 2007?Is there any way to avoid penalty?
...


 If I buy a product from Germany, do I pay VAT ?
...


 Help with taxes!!?
Does anyone know of a website where it explains the meaning of claiming single or married and the amount of dependants? I am married and I would like to have more taken out of my paycheck each week ...


 How can I get less taxes taken away from my paycheck???!!!???!!!?
I make a good income and feel that taxes are killing me. I get paid biweekly and and my check is $2925 and it comes out to $1885 after taxes!?!?!?!!? How can I get this down?

My Dad is ...


 IRS Stimulus check question?
did anyone get their stimulus check yet? How long did it take after your letter came to get it? also what numbers does your last two digets fall under? I know I supost to get mine within this week or ...


 My son is off sick and his employer won't pay him.He paysNI contributions and works full time?
should he be entitled to ...


 PAN Card Allotted or not ?
I have a strange problem. My auditor has filed IT returns on with a PAN No which is claimed to be in somebody else name. How do i find out whats the PAN number alloted to me ? I had applied for PAN ...



T the D
Can someone help me understand this?
Ok, so I just read a news article about the guy who caught the Barry Bonds record breaking homerun ball.

He said that he has no choice but to sell it because he is going to be charged taxes just for owning the ball.

I know our tax systems is all sorts of screwed up, but how the heck can this even be possible? You can really be taxed on an object when you haven't even sold it? Can you also be taxed if someone gives you an extremely expensive gift, even if you have no intention of selling it?

I guess it's true, but it makes me angry and I don't understand it! Maybe someone with experience in tax law could enlighten me on this subject. Or if you'd just like to tell me that you agree with how annoying and wrong it is, you can do that to!
Additional Details
I've been looking into more on my own, and you absolutely CAN be taxed for it, AND he apparently received a bill for the tax owed for owning that ball.

So for those of you who so rudely answered my question: suck it!
                     
 




MICon
Rating
The ball has economic value. He has received an item of great worth.

The Internal Revenue Code in Section 61 states "gross income means all income from whatever source derived". It doesn't matter if the income is in the form of cash or other items. Barter transactions are taxed, buried treasure is taxed, prizes are taxed.

He's not paying taxes for owning the ball - that would be property tax. He's paying taxes for receiving the ball just as if he received a check, or stock, or a case full of cash.

Unless an item is excluded in the code then it is taxable. The exclusions begin in Section 101 and the sections following but there is no exclusion for this type of income.

There is however an exclusion for gifts so No you would not have to pay tax if you receive a very expensive gift. The giver may owe gift tax though for giving the gift. It was the gift tax issue which created all the problems with the McGwire ball in 1998. The IRS was correct that giving the ball away would result in gift tax but the public was outraged and Congress complained and so the IRS backed off.

If you would like more information on this issue then examine the articles from Tax Law Professors Abreu at Temple Law School and Graetz at Yale Law School.


pokerfaces55
no ..
there isn't any taxes on the ball unless its sold
then it becomes ether income or capital gain..
its not a gift ether...
fine line between ball and finding something valuable.. ball has potential value.. but its not taxed until that value is determined...

unlike gifts..
those are untaxed up to whatever amount is set
i think its 10 grand for gifts and 600 grand if the gift is through a death or inheritance

i could be wrong... on the exact numbers.. but thats my thoughts and experiences with this issue


April
I saw it too and i wa wondering why should he be taxed for that ball???? Is that a way to get him to sell the ball or something? All i know is that he is going to be making a lot of money for it once it is sold. Personally I'd sell it regardless but it is stupid they would tax him.


chrisamethyst
Rating
I had no idea you could be taxed just for owning an object as small as a baseball. I guess it's just a curse for owning a piece of history. You know, if this ball was caught before the media made a big deal out of homeruns and how much they were worth...we wouldn't have even seen this guys face.

On another note, I think this guy is just selling the ball because he needs the money. I mean, I think I'd sell the ball too if I was going to get half a million dollars for something that probably cost 3 bucks before Bonds smacked it into the stands.


Easy B Me II
Well you know the IRS motto, "we've got what it takes to take what you've got."


Chanclito
Basically they consider it taxable income, because he could sell it. So he'd probobly have to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars just to keep it. If he sells it he will still have to, but at least he'll have the money.

I personally think he should burn the ball. It's not worth anything in my book!


Jimfix
Rating
Now just settle down for a minute. He did not say a tax attorney or a cpa said that. He said some friends said that. It is pure bunk.


Judy1
Read the articles closely. It doesn't say that the IRS billed him, it says "several people" have told him he would have to pay if he kept the ball. Matt Murphy said that "several people" had told him that he'd be taxed if he kept it. If you read some of the answers on this forum, any day you can find "several people" giving totally wrong answers to questions asked. So why do you "guess it's true" - do you believe everything you read on the Internet or that someone tells you?

In a similar case a few years back, when similar rumors ran rampant, the IRS Commissioner came out with a statement that the idea was crazy.


PepsiLime
Rating
It's the IRS, it doesn't have to make sense, unfortunately. They make the rules, they change the rules, etc.


 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:







Archive: Forum -Forum -Finance - Links - 1 - 2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
The Causes and the Results. 0.024
Copyright (c) 2011 Financial Crisis Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Terms of use - Privacy Policy