Home | Links | Contact Us | Bookmark
Financial Forum Search :
   Homepage      News      Financial Topics     Finance Directories      Financial Forum      Dictionary  
Financial Forum    Taxes
Finance Discussion Forum

 If I sell my horse for $12,000.00, do I have to claim it as income on my taxes?
...


 How are lump sum severance payments taxed?
...


 Most EU immigrants dont pay uk car tax. should we say yeah good luck to tax evaders?
...


 I have a pan number i want my details?
...


 Where's My Tax Rebate?
So the IRS says they started direct depositing the tax rebates on Monday. They're paying it in order of the last 2 digitals of your social security number.

My social ends in 00 ...


 How do I followup with the IRS if the receive my income tax thru mail?
I've sent my income tax thru mail but for some reason i just sent it by regular mail and I didn't certified it at the post office,
How long do they usually give your refund by using ...


 Is there a website where I can check to see if I will qualify for the tax rebate that they are issuing in May?
...


 I did my taxes through Turbo Tax and recieved it direct depsited through SBBT, How would I recieve my rebate?
...


 If I owe back taxes on prior returns, but have payment plans set up to pay off, will I get stimulus check?
...


 Does HR BLOCK or Jackson hewitt charge a percentage of your return for their fees?
How do they figure how much it costs for them to do your taxes? I did them myself but Im not sure if they are right? So I did the work but they will get my $...not fair. Anyway, if I am getting back ...


 Why don't people in the South have to pay income taxes?
I was looking through some cities on Bestplaces.net and I noticed that in many Southern states there is a 0% income tax. Missouri, one state I'm interested in, has a brutal 7% income tax. What ...


 PLEASE READ! Pls help me with my question! PLESE READ!?
I want to know if i should claim my son the year income tax or should i let his dad claim for him this year2007? i just got a job this octomber2007. his dad claim both his son and myself last year2006...


 Can I do my income tax return without my w-2?
I have my last paycheck stub....


 Do you favor shutting down the IRS in turn for a 10% flat tax ?
This would be a flat rate tax, not an actual flat tax...
Studies have shown that this model could actually produce MORE revenue into the federal government.

The IRS is spending ...


 My income is rs345000. i want to save money and tax, how?
...


 If i want to become a CPA (Certified Public Accountant) what tipe of accounting should i major in?
theres soooo many type of accounting majors...its almost confusing...i'd just like to know which one should i tackle..i kno i want to be an accountant...but which one would be appropriate for a C...


 If my income is less than the prescribed IT limit should I file IT returns for that year.?
I have been filing IT returns regularly. Filed IT returns for the financial Year 2006-2007. I resigned from my job in march 2007. Earnings for the year 2007- 2008 less than the prescribed limit for ...


 Do I have to file taxes if I only worked on week in 2007?
I only worked on week and that is all that I worked in 2007. My boyfriend claimed me and our daughter cause he supported us. I did not file because I only had worked that short time. Do I need to ...


 Irs stimulus check r they coming out again?
i hear that there is another stimulus check coming out . if this true do anyone know when.
...


 I just read that you are more likely to be audited by the IRS if you file early. Is this true?
...



great_and_mighty_ada...
Which is a better investment - 7% tax-deferred or 9% taxable?
Assume:
- I have a marginal tax bracket of 30%
- I am investing for a 15-year time horizon.
- Tax is paid yearly on taxable interest.
- Tax is paid at end-of-term on tax-deferred interest.
- The principal is not tax deductible.

If you can provide a calculator for this kind of stuff, that would be appreciated as well.

I am comparing corporate bonds in a Roth IRA vs. Prosper.com in a taxable account.
Additional Details
To clarify.

The Roth IRA is 7%.
The fully taxable account is 9%.
                     
 




Feeling Mutual
The Roth IRA at 9% taxable is better, because this is a Roth IRA, which is tax free gains. So you don't pay any taxes on the gains, even though it is taxable.

Fidelity.com has calculators, that show taxable and non-taxable figures.


stephenweinstein
Rating
1. Ronald EB is wrong; A Roth is only tax free if you leave the earnings in it until age 59 1/2 or in certain other cases. If you take the earnings sooner, there are taxes and penalties.

2. If the taxable account earns 9% and you pay 30% in taxes, then, for each $ in the taxable account at the start of the year, you earn 9 cents and pay 2.7 cents in taxes, leaving you with $1.063 at the end of the year. If the Roth earns 7%, then for each $ in the account at the start of the year, you have $1.07 at the end of the year, which is $0.007 more. This may not seem like much, but remember that this happens every year and it adds up. However, if you do not leave the earnings in the account until when they can be distributed tax-free, then the taxes and penalties may exceed the cumulative advantages of $0.007 per year.

Why not Prosper.com in a Roth IRA at 9%?


PepsiLime
Rating
9% taxable at 30% tax rate results in 6.3% after tax return. Roth IRA is the better bet, and it's also not-taxable as well, so that's even a better bet too boot.


DrIG
Rating
I vote for the Roth.

Your money is growing tax deferred for 15 years. Reinvest the bond dividends. You will be better off.

Warning some bonds are not good investments. The bonds may be worth less when you take them out. The company may fail and you might not get your money back.


ninasgramma
Rating
The Roth wins, since your after-tax yield on the bonds is 6.3% after federal taxes, versus 7% inside the Roth. You don't need any calculator to see this.

Also, as long as you hold the Roth for five years and do not withdraw money before 59.5 (or meet one of the exceptions), then you pay no tax on the Roth distributions. The Roth is not tax-deferred. Contributions are with after-tax money but all earnings are tax-free for qualifying distributions.


skipper
A Roth IRA is not tax deferred...the gains are NEVER taxed and the principal has already been taxed. A regular IRA is tax deferred; the tax on both the principal and the gains is deferred until they are withdrawn.


bostonianinmo
Rating
The 9% taxable investment is 6.3% net of tax. Therefore the 7% non-taxable is the better return.

A Roth isn't tax-deferred, by the way. Accumulation is TAX FREE with a Roth.


Judy1
Rating
If it's just tax-deferred and you expect to still be in the 30% bracket when the tax is due, then you'll have to pay taxes on it at the end, so won't save a whole lot - so the 9% would be better. If the 7% is tax-EXEMPT, which appreciation in a Roth IRA would be, then it would be better than the 9% in your tax bracket.


 Enter Your Message or Comment


User Name:  
User Email:   
Post a comment:







Archive: Forum -Forum -Finance - Links - 1 - 2 - RSS - All RSS Feeds
The Causes and the Results. 0.044
Copyright (c) 2011 Financial Crisis Tuesday, May 29, 2012 - Terms of use - Privacy Policy